Search This Blog

Sunday, June 9, 2019

“…Lutherans die well” (Part 3 of 3): amusing fables of Catholics and Jesuits

      This concludes from Part 2 (Part 1). —  Now Walther defends against not just one fable but three.  And in the process he teaches us "Protestant schoolchildren" just exactly what a "Protestant" is.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 
Roman Catholics live well, but Lutherans die well.
[Part 3 of 3; By C.F.W. Walther – Der Lutheraner v. 24, no. 18 (May 1868), p. 139]

It is amusing that the Louisville Faith Messenger relates that Melanchthon said to his mother: “The Protestant doctrine is easier, but the Catholic doctrine is safer.”  
Every good Protestant schoolchild knows, however, that the Lutherans were called by the name Protestant only after that incident because on April 29, 1529 [sic? or April 19] they entered a solemn written Protestation against the imperial annulment of [the ban the Diet of] Speyer [1526].

Hey, hey, Mr. Papists, may that not happen to you! As is generally known, the Frenchman [Antoine] Varillas was the first to invent that fable, although Varillas lied even more grossly by saying that Melanchthon did not say the words given by the Faith Messenger [page 139, col. 2] to his mother on her deathbed, but on his own deathbed, 31 years after her death!! (For it is well known that Melanchthon did not die until 1560.)  But although the Louisville Faith Messenger omitted the fiction of Varillas where he had betrayed himself, the Faith Messenger did not find his fiction bad enough. While Varillas reports that Melanchthon said to his mother: “The religion of Luther is more plausible, the Roman safer," yet according to the Faith Messenger Melanchthon is quoted to have said: “The Protestant (!) teaching is easier, but the Catholic is safer.” The difference between Varillas and the Faith Messenger is that he tells us that Melanchthon said those words to his mother after she had died 31 years before, which Varillas hadn't thought about at the time, while the Faith Messenger tells us that Melanchthon called the Lutherans ‘Protestants’ even before their “Protestation”, which is about the same as if someone told him that Columbus had said on his journey across the Atlantic Ocean: “I want to see if I can not discover America!” Who would believe that? —
The Faith Messenger again looks for when it can twist a story or invent something that has not actually happened. (Such was the case, for example, of the purely fabricated story by the papists of the Donatio Constantini [Donation of Constantine]. It must study the history of the time to which it wants to transfer its made-up story, so that it does not indeed “shoot a goat” [i.e. make a big mistake], by which it betrays itself. This can easily happen, especially when it again commits such an anachronism [chronological error], as the scholars would call it.
Of course, the Faith Messenger would do best if from now on it would invent no more stories, but always tell everything as it really happened. Although this is not a principle of the Jesuits, rather a true Lutheran one, we should think that even a Jesuit would not be ashamed to act accordingly.   W[alther].
= = = = = = = =  End of article  = = = = = = = = 

      A recent popular book on Luther by James Reston Jr., Luther's Fortress p. 241, has reminded the world, even if the LC-MS does not, that “the Roman Catholic ban on Luther ‘and all his followers’ is still in effect”.  That ban was upheld at the Diet of Speyer 1529 against the Protestants, i.e. the Lutherans.  But as Walther's article shows, there is no ban on Catholic fables of Church History.

      The accounts of Herman Otten in Christian News of his final days on his deathbed would indicate the same faith as Melanchthon's mother on her deathbed – “justified and blessed before God alone by believing in Jesus ​​Christ” – a Lutheran faith that died well.

Thursday, June 6, 2019

“…Lutherans die well” (Part 2 of 3)

      This continues from Part 1. —  Walther now shows exactly where the Catholic paper promoted fiction. Walther and his associates showed an amazing capacity to keep up with what other religious papers were putting out to their people.  And when he witnessed the lies of a Roman Catholic publication, he sprung into action.
      Melanchthon is perhaps known among orthodox Lutherans for his doctrinal weakening against the Roman party after Luther's death.  But in this history, Walther relates a most comforting episode from his life.  Lutherans can be strengthened in their faith when hearing that the author of much of the early portions of the Lutheran Confession was strong in faith with his dying mother.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 
Roman Catholics live well, but Lutherans die well.
[Part 2; By C.F.W. Walther – Der Lutheraner v. 24, no. 18 (May 1868), p. 139]

The opposite of this narrative is the truth about Melanchthon’s mother, who remarried twice after the early death of Melanchthon's father, did not become Lutheran, but remained in the Catholic Church for the sake of her strictly Catholic husbands until shortly before her death. She had even let one of her daughters from her second marriage become a nun in Neuenburg.

But when at the beginning of March of 1529 Melanchthon traveled to the fashionable Diet of Speyer [Speier, Spires] with the Elector of Saxony and finding that it was delayed, he had to spend his free time with his old mother and his eager Lutheran brother George Schwarzerd, in Bretten, who was the mayor there. He found his elderly mother was near death. However, she asked her son what to believe among the scholars’ quarrels in order to be able to die peacefully. What did Melanchthon do?  He asked her, while near death, what she prayed for and what she believed.  

Now when she confessed that she was relying on nothing but the precious merit and blood of her dear Lord Jesus ​​Christ and addressed her prayers to him alone, Melanchthon strengthened her in her faith and assured her that she would die peacefully in these beliefs.

This is exactly the striking proof that, although Roman Catholics live well, Lutherans die well. For in her life she had relied on her miserable works, and, instead of Christ alone, called on Mary and other saints and sought their help. But in her death, as did once the dying Duke George of Saxony, she threw this all away, and in a good Lutheran way would become justified and blessed before God alone by believing in Jesus ​​Christ. –
= = = = = = = = =  concluded in Part 3  = = = = = = = = =

      Just as the Florida martyrs were not actually Lutherans but Calvinists (Huguenots), so Melanchthon’s mother was not Lutheran, but remained Roman Catholic during her life.  Ah, but she would die well, and so died a Lutheran.  So died all the Lutheran Martyrs.
      Walther interjects a bit of church history that is omitted almost everywhere else in the histories of the Reformation.  It is the strikingly similar situation of the notorious Duke George (or George the Bearded), who relentlessly persecuted the Lutherans during his lifetime as a Roman Catholic.  But in death, he turned “Lutheran”.  This is related elsewhere by Franz Pieper in his Christian Dogmatics, vol. 2, p. 255: "Duke George of Saxony died confessing the doctrine of justification by faith which throughout his life he had denied over against Luther."
      A member of the LC-MS contacted me privately some time ago thanking me for my blog. Their past family history included Lutherans, Roman Catholics and then there were Southern Baptists, but now this person turned Lutheran. May this series be a comfort to them as a Lutheran.
      In the concluding Part 3, Walther shows that he is not yet done with his "fable busting" of Roman Catholics.

Monday, June 3, 2019

Memories of Dr. Franz Pieper by L. Fürbringer (#1), on Pieper anniversary: † June 3, 1931

Prof. Ludwig Fürbringer

      Today marks the 88th anniversary of the "home going" of Dr. Franz Pieper.  To commemorate this, I would begin a series of blogs publishing my translation of Prof. Ludwig Fürbringer's string of articles on his personal memories of Pieper.  The subject matter is more wide ranging than what he covered separately in his series "Dr. Franz Pieper as Theologian".  I have already published small portions of this series elsewhere (here and here) and so I will not repeat the portion that I included in the series on "Copernicanism".  Otherwise most of this series will be first published here in English. —  Some of this material may only be of interest to historians as Fürbringer writes of individuals apart from Pieper, but most of the material touches on spiritual matters of importance to all Christians.  We now begin our journey with Dr. Fürbringer to learn more of the man, Franz Pieper – "The Twentieth Century Luther". 

Translation by BackToLuther; highlighting is mine; hyperlinks added. Text extracted from Der Lutheraner, vol. 87 (1931), p. 250-252.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 
(page 250, col. 2)
Memories of Dr. Franz Pieper.
by Ludwig Fürbringer – [1.]
------------
As we already said in the number of Der Lutheraner in which the blessed passing [Heimgang, “home going”]  of our faithful and much-beloved Dr. Pieper was announced, we now send to the valued readers of this paper some memories of his long and richly blessed life. A number of district synods which gathered in June have already duly given thought of him in one way or another: in South Dakota, North Dakota, and Montana, Michigan, Ontario, and Manitoba and Saskatchewan districts, as today's number announces at other places.  In the Colorado district meeting I had to represent the President of the Synod. I was allowed there to report after the last segment, where Dr. L. Wessel spoke on the royal office of Christ and his kingdom of honor and glory, something about the last weeks and the blessed passing of our teacher. Certainly some pastors and congregations have commemorated the departed teacher in their services without any further reason. And the Western District has especially recommended to their congregations to hold a memorial service as Pieper was a member of this district for fifty-three years.  In our Concordia Theological Monthly, in one of the upcoming numbers, Dr. Pieper’s importance as a theologian and churchman in a German and English article will be appreciated. A popular biography is in preparation.
Therefore, the following memories, as I would like to present at this point, will now be kept very personal. So I will describe as best I can the man who was first my esteemed teacher, who I then joined at his side as a younger colleague, and who together with me almost thirty-eight (page 251, col. 1) years, was allowed to labor at our seminary.

= = = = = = = = =  continued in Part 2  = = = = = = = = =
Part 2 was published under my series on Copernicanism here and so will not be repeated here.  It covers Pieper's early life in Germany and his acquaintance with the Lisco-Knak affair. —  Fürbringer's series spanned 6 issues of Der Lutheraner.  My series will split this into even more sections.  This adds to the earlier series "Dr. Franz Pieper as Theologian" and "Pieper's Sermons"
      There was another series written about this same time by Prof. W.H.T. Dau: "Dr. Francis Pieper the Churchman" and is available from CTS-FW here (formatted text here). However I have not highlighted Prof. Dau's works, even though written in English, as they show more of the tendency toward what the Missouri Synod transformed into, the LC-MS. Although Ludwig Fürbringer exhibited some of these same tendencies, yet he offered a better testimony to Pieper's greatness as a theologian. — In the following Part 3…

= = = = = = = = = = = = = =  Table of Contents  = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Part 1 – This blog with introduction; personal memories of Fürbringer
Part 2 – Birth place, Pomerania; near to Pastor Gustav Knak (from Copernicanism series)
Part 3 – Early training, language proficiency, especially Latin
Part 4 – Concordia student; pastor Wisc; Walther's recommendation: Concordia professor; August Pieper
Part 5 – trained in Dogmatics by Walther; Greek & Latin: "like water"; captivating Pieper-Conferences 1880/81
Part 6 – Pieper’s essays; 1st Brief Statement; Fürbringer called to faculty; relations with WELS
Part 7 – Fürbringer- new Prof.: “learned constantly”; "translated justification into daily life"
Part 8 – Christliche Dogmatik – the simple, clear Scriptural truth; “this instrument of the Lutheran Church”
Part 9 – Pieper’s great knowledge; humorous; Navy league; Vatican ‘For Rent’?; Pelikan, Lueking, Danker
Part 10 – Convention essays; Germany, Australia, missions; breakdown, racism?; “winged words”
Part 11 – Joyful- “lay the heart… on doctrine of justification” (not psychology)
Part 12 – Congregations, congregational schools; C.C. Schmidt, model preacher
Part 13 – Anniversaries- Professor- 25th & 50th (1903/1928); Chinese congratulate, but Th. Graebner?
Part 14 – Pieper "now grown old", "thought of written word"; not lonely
Part 15 – Last Words (again); Open Heaven; Albrecht Ritschl's deathbed conversion
Part 16 – How did Pieper die?; “this was not death”; sola gratia; Copernicus… again?

Sunday, June 2, 2019

“…but Lutherans die well”– for Otten family: Herman Otten, † 4/24/2019 (Part 1 of 3)


      In reading the May 6, 2019 issue of Christian News, an issue in honor of the passing of the paper's founder Herman Otten, I came across Managing Editor Ruth Rethemeyer's quote (p. 4-5) from Roman Catholic Peter Manns’ 1983 book Martin Luther: An Illustrated Biography, p. 219: 
“How silly that expression was that for centuries we believed hit the nail on the head: ‘To lead a good life one must be Lutheran; to die a good death, Catholic.’ Anyone who follows Luther will live well and die even better, for at the end of the dark tunnel stands someone who loves us and to whom we can look forward. That is Luther's ecumenical legacy for which we should give thanks.”
The "silly expression" that Manns refers to has a history that is explained quite well in an article that C.F.W. Walther wrote in 1868 in his Der Lutheraner magazine.  Walther was defending against fables promoted by Roman Catholic publications in America.  And so to take the opportunity that Rethemeyer presented, I would publish this essay of Walther to comfort the family of the departed Lutheran pastor (emeritus) Herman Otten:

Translation by BackToLuther; highlighting, bolding is mine, underlining follows Walther's emphasis; hyperlinks added.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 
Roman Catholics live well, but Lutherans die well.

In the Catholic Faith Messenger [Katholischer Glaubensbote] (Louisville, Ky) from April 29 [1868], the old wives’ tale is again served up to ignorant readers that Melanchthon had said to his dying mother, who had been seduced to the Lutheran faith, that for a Lutheran, life was good, but for a “Catholic” it meant dying well. The fable-messenger tells us, as follows:
“When Melanchthon's mother, who had been persuaded by her son to fall away from the Catholic Church and convert to the Reformation, was lying on her deathbed, she was known to have summoned her son and solemnly asked him, ‘Son! On your advice, I left the Catholic Church, and accepted the new religion; so I implore you by the living God, [page 139, col. 1] tell me without a doubt what faith I should die in.’ Melanchthon bowed his head and remained in silence for some time; childlike love fought with the pride of the reformer within his heart. ‘Mother’, he said at last, ‘the Protestant doctrine is easier, but the Catholic doctrine is safer.’ This is the most striking proof that life in Protestantism is considered easier and better as with death is in Catholicism.” So far the Faith Messenger.
The opposite of this narrative is the truth about Melanchthon’s mother…
= = = = = = = = = = =  continued in Part 2  = = = = = = = = = =

      I would call attention to Walther's use of quote marks around the name “Catholic” .  He is pointing out that the use of that name, which means "universal", is a misnomer, or "name-only" in that the Roman church is certainly not the Church Universal, but became a sect with its falsification of the pure Gospel.  What purports today to be "evangelical catholicity" is not a discovery of the doctrine of the Church Universal, but a falling back to the doctrine of the Roman Catholic Church.  —  Walther is going to reveal more than one fiction in this Catholic fable… much more... beginning in the next Part 2. (concludes in Part 3)

Saturday, May 11, 2019

Florida's true martyrs: massacred by “holy Catholic faith”; “evangelical catholicity”?, Part 2

      Continued from Part 1. Pastor Piepkorn, after his introductory remarks, now gives his summary of the history of these "Lutheran Martyrs" of Florida. Afterwards we will compare it to the report by C.F.W. Walther 68 years earlier:
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =  Part 2 of 2  = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =

The Lutheran martyrs of Florida [1] were members of a naval mission sent by the king of France [2] upon the urging of Admiral de Coligny to colonize the east coast of Florida in the name of the French crown, and a settlement was established at the mouth of St. John’s River [Ft. Caroline].

Philip II of Spain sent Captain General Pedro Menéndez to destroy the colony, and in 1565 he established a base at St. Augustine. Taking the offensive to ward off this threat to the peace of the French colony, Jean Ribault of Dieppe endeavored to attack St. Augustine by sea, but was prevented from achieving victory by the tide and by the outbreak of a violent storm, which shipwrecked his flotilla off the coast. Menéndez immediately attacked the French settlement by land and destroyed it. The shipwrecked French sailors landed on an island near St. Augustine, where Menendez succeeded in inducing about 215 to surrender unconditionally. Ordering them bound, he demanded that they declare their faith. Ten confessed themselves to be Roman Catholics and were spared, along with a few artisans whose services were required by the Spaniards. The remainder, having refused to renounce their Lutheran belief, [1] were ferried to the mainland in small groups and marched northward. As they reached a line which Menendez had drawn in the sand they were set upon and murdered in cold blood.
Kill Lutherans
and Lutheranism in America.
A fortnight later, on Oct. 12, an additional seventy-five, among them Ribault himself, were similarly dispatched in a repetition of the gory tragedy. In recording the event, the Rev. Fr. Francisco Lopez de Mendoza Grajales, the chaplain of Menendez’s expedition, notes in his chronicle that the martyrs of Florida “were executed because they were Lutherans and enemies of our holy [Roman] Catholic faith.” [3]
= = = = = = = = =   End of article  = = = = = = = = = = =     [The original article may be viewed here]
Notes:
  1. Piepkorn offers no explanation, as Walther does in 1872, that Ribault's French party did not call themselves Lutherans but Huguenots – essentially Calvinists – a separated sect from Lutheranism.
  2. The "king of France" was Charles IX of France, also the namesake of Florida's Fort Caroline.
  3. Piepkorn omits a detail that Walther covered in 1872, a juicy postscript revealing that 2 years after this massacre the French harshly avenged this crime, but not as Lutherans, rather as Frenchmen.
What gives this history notoriety is that the one who gave witness to the true reason for the massacre was not a Frenchman or any “Protestant”, but the Roman Catholic priest.
      When one just begins to research the history of this incident on the Internet, one is bombarded with web sites that cover not these martyrs executed as Lutherans, but rather the "La Florida martyrs", or Roman Catholic "martyrs" who were put to death by native Americans and Carolina Colony soldiers (Colony history). They do not speak of the French retaliation that followed 2 years after this massacre.  But it was the Roman Catholics who first made their intentions clear for the "holy Catholic faith" in America, that those Lutherans or any who were considered to be harboring the faith of the Lutheran Reformation were targets to be executed, nay, massacred. —

      However the reason why I am publishing this essay is not so much to bring the Florida massacre to memory again, since Walther already did that 68 years before this essay, but to highlight the irony of the writer of this essay, Arthur Carl Piepkorn.
      Today's defenders of Piepkorn and his "evangelical catholicity" may interject that his account of this incident was not so different from Walther's in 1872.  That may be true to a certain extent, but Walther knew the papists better than Piepkorn.  Walther, unlike Piepkorn, knew that he did not need to gloss over that the martyrs were not actually Lutherans, he told the history exactly as it was.  The French party of Ribault were Huguenots, i.e. Calvinists.  And the story would lose its notoriety except for the fact that they were considered Lutherans by the Catholics, as their own priest proudly proclaimed!

      Lest any reader wonder that I am improperly characterizing the theology of Pastor (and Professor) Piepkorn, I would point to the testimony of the well-known Father Richard John Neuhaus (see appendix below), a Concordia Seminary trained Lutheran pastor who famously left Lutheranism to be a Roman Catholic priest.  In his 2006 book Catholic Matters, p. 55-56, he revealed who was the greatest influence in his decision to turn away from Lutheranism… to Catholicism (my emphasis): 
“Although he remained a Lutheran until his death, at age sixty-six, in 1973, Piepkorn gave me an understanding of Lutheranism that required my becoming Catholic. … The Church is not…formed by…formulas such as ‘justification by faith alone’”.
Another witness to this would be Robert Louis Wilken, another LCMS Lutheran-turned-Catholic.

A confessed catholic,
not with ambivalence.
America's Luther:
C.F.W. Walther
      The last line of Piepkorn's hymn stanza asks "Who follows in their train?" But how is one to be a Lutheran today in America, one who "follows in their train"?  Is it not to stand with the "Old Lutherans" of the old Missouri Synod of a century ago, the ones so vilified in the 1910 Catholic Encyclopedia?  Is it not to understand that “The pope did not propose that the [Vatican II] council revise or change Roman Catholic doctrine.” (Meyer-Tjernagel, A History of Western Christianity, p 271)  Is it not to stand fast against not only the Roman Catholic Church, but against the Romanizing Lutheran teachers in the LCMS, epitomized by the writer of this essay, Arthur Carl Piepkorn?  True Lutherans stand fast on sola fide, "without the deeds of the law" (Ro 3:28), that salvation is entirely and alone by God's grace.  Therefore they do not join in spirit (or work) with those who vilify (i.e. massacre) true Lutheranism. 

      What did the father's of the United States of America have in mind with their ideal of "freedom of religion"?  They had in mind to prohibit the civil power of the Roman Catholic Church to rule, so that in America one would not be forced out for not bowing to the Pope.  George Washington hardly had in mind to allow papal power to rule religion in America in his farewell address.
[Other Florida massacre histories available here and here]
= = = = = = = = = = = = =
2019-05-26: Appendix I: For additional material on Neuhaus, see Robert Preus's citations from him in his 1970 essay "Confessional Subscription" p. 45 n. 12 & 13.
2023-11-07: See the Catholic "Coming Home" based website here on Neuhaus.