Search This Blog

Friday, November 20, 2026

BWC3p: Baptism; Lord's Supper

      This continues from Part BWC3o in a series (Table of Contents in Part BWC1) presenting Walther's edition of Baier's Compendium of Positive Theology. — Walther's added italicizing for emphasis of certain words and phrases are especially helpful in understanding the most important points in his quotes from the Lutheran and ancient fathers. — From pages 477-496:

Notable Quotes: (Italics and bolding follow the original. All quotes not from Baier are from Walther's additions of quotes from third parties. Authors are indicated in bold text. Red text indicates my comments.)

477: Baier: "For to infants indeed, equally to all, faith is conferred and sealed by baptism for the first time,…But to those adults only who have conceived faith from the Word before the reception of baptism, baptism seals and confirms that faith."
478: Gerhard: "The infants of the faithful are no less than the rest 'by nature children of wrath' Eph. 2:3, 'conceived and born in sins' Ps. 51:7, 'born of an unclean seed' Job 14:4, 'are flesh of flesh' John 3:6"
478: Quenstedt, Antithesis: "The Calvinists, who teach that the children of faithful parents are born holy, immune from all guilt, pleasing to God, and, by hereditary right, accepted from the mother's womb"
479: Luther: "you hold that young children do not believe…, and yet you baptize them. Then I said: It would be better to baptize no child at all anywhere than to baptize without faith"
481: Gerhard: "We demonstrate that adults must be instructed in the Christian religion, and must embrace and profess it, before they are admitted to baptism"
482: C. Dieterich: "All individual infants who are baptized according to Christ's institution are regenerated; but adults are not all, but only those who believe and do not resist the work of the Holy Spirit."
483: Luther: "Where Satan could not extinguish the virtue of baptism in little children, he nevertheless prevailed to extinguish it in all adults, so that now there is hardly anyone who remembers being baptized"
484: Luther: "For human weakness, conscious of its sins, finds it exceedingly difficult to believe that it is saved or can be saved, and yet, unless it believes this, it cannot be saved, because it does not believe the divine truth that promises salvation."
485: Luther: "many rashly leap from the ship into the sea and perish; these are those who, having abandoned the faith of the promise, precipitate themselves into sin. Yet the ship itself remains, and it travels its course intact; and if anyone by any grace can return to the ship, he will be carried to life, not on a plank, but on the ship itself."
486: Gerhard, on the rites surrounding Baptism: "We also retain these rites in our churches, because the sacraments are not bare and idle spectacles, but were instituted to both confirm faith and more clearly explain the promise"
487: Baier: These rites "should not be abolished or omitted for the sake of pleasing the heterodox who lie in wait for our liberty, or who attribute sanctity to Christian infants as if it were hereditary, by which they are already in the state of grace."

489 ff.: On the Lord's Supper 
489: Baier: "Not as if it [baptism] were abrogated, but as a sacrament of confirmation, to be administered only to those who have already been initiated."
489: Quenstedt: The New Testament: "the testator here is Christ, sealing the testament with his death; the heirs are all believers; the witnesses are the apostles; the notaries are the evangelists and Paul…the seal is the body of Christ in the bread, the blood in the wine"
489: Calov: "it is strange that anyone should call these words of Christ into question. But the Calvinists not only deny that these are the foundation of this doctrine, but they outright reject them as proof"
 490: Calov: "what all those who from chapter John 6 attempt to elicit the true sense of Christ's words and consequently abuse a foreign place to distort the proper seat of the doctrine" [Prof. David Scaer distorts the "proper seat of the doctrine" by his use of John 6. Scaer uses Calvinist methods  by "abusing a foreign place".]
491: Hutter: "blessed Luther is free from all reproach, who wished to explain these two questions from their proper foundations,…to assert them against the babblings of the sacramentarians"
493: Formula of Concord: "For the true and almighty words of Jesus Christ, which he spoke in the first institution, were not only powerful in the first Supper, but they endure, are valid, work, and are still powerful"
495: Luther: "Paul is speaking of the bread in the Sacrament, which Christ broke and which the apostles also broke afterward; this breaking is nothing other than making pieces or distributing, in the Hebrew manner, Isa. 58:7: 'Break your bread to the hungry'" [Against Reformed; see next item.]
496: Quenstedt: "the Calvinists, who insist on the breaking of the bread as necessary in the very act of the supper…"

In the next Part BWC3q…

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments only accepted when directly related to the post.