Search This Blog

Thursday, July 10, 2014

Commenter: Not prudent– those in hell as redeemed?

A comment has come in regarding a bold statement that Walther made in the LDJ essay Part 28.  
I’ll refer to the commenter as “Mr. K”.  He said:
Those in hell have forfeited their redemption. It is not prudent to speak of those in hell as redeemed; better, they were redeemed. One can not possess what he has cast off in rejection.
Mr. K’s comment concerned this statement of Walther:
“also those are redeemed that are sweating in hell”
So, would you, Mr. K, also say that it was not prudent for
  • Walther to say “"…you often hear pastors preach, 'You are saved if you believe.' What they should be saying is, 'You are saved so that you might believe.'"”?
  • Walther to say about an impenitent sinner after absolution, that he has no benefit by his unbelief, that “However, this is certain that you have been absolved”?  (from The Proper Distinction…, pg 376, see here; see also my letter to Prof. Eugene Klug, †2003)
  • Franz Pieper to say that the Lutheran Confessions teach “threefold universalism”?
  • Luther to preach in a sermon on John 1:29 that “Yes, He assumes not only my sins but also those of the whole world, from Adam down to the very last mortal.”?
  • the Saviour to say “For God so loved the world” and “that the world through him might be saved”? (while He also said “he that believeth not is condemned already”) - John 3:16-18
  • the Saviour to call Judas “Friend” (Matt. 26:50) for he surely knew Judas, as he approached the Saviour to betray Him, was going the Hell?
  • Peter to say that the “false prophets ... [deny] the Lord that bought them” (2 Peter 2:1)? ... would you say that Peter was referring only to future “false prophets” and not past “false prophets” who are “sweating in hell”?
  • God to say through the prophet Ezekiel that “I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked”, i.e. the unbelievers? (Ezekiel 33:11)

A so-called “prudence” on this point is the starting point of a misunderstanding of “grace”,  gives me the thought that somehow my faith makes me better than those in Hell... but I'm not.  I am no better than Judas.  I am no better than those of Sodom and Gomorrha.  A so-called “prudence” on this point begins to take away my faith… that somehow my faith makes me a better person before God than those who rejected their Saviour.
Walther showed prudence, but it was not to take away from his major premise.  He was careful in the SCR 1872 essay to use the proper word regarding unbelievers (see here) that though they were truly redeemed, yet their pardon was not accepted in true faith.  And in this 1859 LDJ essay, he used prudence in relation to the false teaching of Antinomians, but this never ever took away the sweet Gospel, but rather upheld its sweetness.  No the great charge against the true Evangelical message was by the Papists as they cried out against the “Protestants” that they gave the people “license”, as if to say they gave the people license to sin.

I confess: If those sweating in Hell were, but are not now redeemed, then I am going to Hell.  Indeed, it was this very forcefulness of Walther that pulled me out of my wretchedness...

Indeed, for this very reason I warned the generally faithful Prof. Eugene Klug (†2003), who even now is largely forgotten in the LC-MS because of his testimony against Hermann Sasse's error) concerning this false prudence…   To his credit, even though Prof. Klug responded to me twice, he did not refute my major point to him, a point that is essentially identical to Walther’s “imprudent” statement – or what I would call Walther’s Last Word.
– – – – – – – – – – – – – –
But isn't there a contradiction even in the way you express your objection?
“Those in hell have forfeited their redemption.”  and “One can not possess what he has cast off in rejection.”
Does not this say that those “sweating in Hell” are the ones who did the forfeiting, not God? … that they are the ones at fault, not God?  Does it not admit that that redemption was valid for them and the only reason for the use of a past tense is because they refused by their unbelief the pardon “while it is day”, not because God withdrew His payment also for them?  
– – – – – – – – – – – – –
I am concerned that the major point of your comment is that

“It is not prudent to speak of those in hell as redeemed; better, they were redeemed.”

This statement is very much like the remark Prof. Kurt Marquart made on the SCR 1872 essay:
...one must... avoid one-sided overstatements (e.g. "all the damned in hell receive the status of pure, forgiven saints and children of God")
Also like the statement of WELS DP Jon Buchholz who said:
There are many impenitent and unbelieving people in the world who embrace God’s forgiveness wrongly and imagine it to be theirs
Those who make “awkward” or “one-sided overstatements” or “caricatures” [Hartman of Kokomo?, Larry Darby?, GJ?, etc, etc] only attempt to paint God’s surpassing grace as something twisted.  But that does not stop Walther (or Luther) from presenting the pure, sweet Gospel.

I implore you to read again the “King’s pardon” analogy of Luther and Walther.  Did they say that the “King’s pardon” was withdrawn because the “pardonees” refused the pardon?  No.  No, those “sweating in Hell” will have exceedingly harsh torment (Luke 16:24) for they will know that the gift was also given to them and they rejected it (Luke 14:18), as you, Mr. K, well say, “One can not possess what he has cast off in rejection”.

No.  I will throw off all so-called “prudence” which makes me begin to doubt my redemption, for I was in Hell in my unbelief until the Saviour in so many ways showed me His universal grace.  As for example the lawyer in the account of the Good Samaritan wanted to justify himself, to justify himself before others, even those “sweating in Hell”, and so the Saviour’s preaching of the Law was not to get him to reform his life, but to repudiate his own righteousness, and see the true Saviour of the world standing before him.
– – – – – – – – – – – – – –
As I reviewed past blogs, it struck me that you, Mr. K, in an earlier comment, did not raise an objection of “imprudence” against Franz Pieper’s statement of the “threefold universalism” of the Lutheran Confessions.  No, rather you said:
“All are saved; some are saved. The saved are those who have faith. The unsaved are those that reject their salvation on account of unbelief.”
How well you stated this! (cf. John 3:16-18)  Then you related that you came to this understanding by “the fine writings” of the WELS (a former member of the Synodical Conference that agreed to SCR 1872) on the doctrine of Election:
What brought much of this into focus for me as a former WELsian who was suspended for taking issue with these 'caricatures', are the fine writings in the WELS essay files regarding Election and the controversies regarding it.”
You can largely thank the Formula of Concord of the Lutheran Confessions for your understanding… doesn’t that make you a Confessional Lutheran?  I suspect that paragraph # 28 of the section “XI. Election” from the “Thorough Declaration” (or “Solid Declaration”) has the most impact on our subject here.  Franz Pieper used this to bolster his striking “threefold universalism” statement:
Therefore, if we wish to consider our eternal election to salvation with profit, we must in every way hold sturdily and firmly to this, that, as the preaching of repentance, so also the promise of the Gospel is universalis (universal), that is, it pertains to all men, Luke 24:47. For this reason Christ has commanded that repentance and remission of sins should be preached in His name among all nations. For God loved the world and gave His Son, John 3:16. Christ bore the sins of the world, John 1:29, gave His flesh for the life of the world, John 6:51; His blood is the propitiation for the sins of the whole world, 1 John 1:7; 2:2. Christ says: Come unto Me, all ye that labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest, Matt. 11:28. God hath concluded them all in unbelief, that He might have mercy upon all, Rom. 11:32. The Lord is not willing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance, 2 Pet. 3:9. The same Lord over all is rich unto all that call upon Him, Rom. 10:12. The righteousness of God, which is by faith of Jesus Christ, unto all and upon all them that believe, Rom. 3:22. This is the will of Him that sent Me, that every one that seeth the Son and believeth on Him may have everlasting life, John 6:40. Likewise it is Christ's command that to all in common to whom repentance is preached this promise of the Gospel also should be offered Luke 24:47; Mark 16:15.

I believe that in this paragraph #28, you are hearing the heart of the blessed Martin Chemnitz, the “Second Martin”.  And that Walther’s bold statement of
“also those are redeemed that are sweating in hell”
is far from being “imprudent” but rather the signal that C.F.W. Walther is not only The American Luther, but I would now, after your comment, also call him the “Third Martin”... and Franz Pieper the “Fourth Martin”.

Indeed, Mr. K, I must thank you for your comment, not for the objection you raise, but to once again dig deeply into Luther, Walther and Pieper to find out again the answer to the question:
Did he really say that?
...those outrageously bold statements… statements which clearly answer this most basic question of Christianity: “What must I do to be saved?”

Nothing, only believe.  Nothing, just open your mouth wide… Nothing, just sit there and make room in your lap for the Greatest News, the Greatest Treasure that man could never dream of (1 Cor. 2:9)… only believe the Good News:
Isaiah 55:1 –  Every one that thirsteth, come ye to the waters, and he that hath no money; come ye, buy, and eat; yea, come, buy wine and milk without money and without price.

Wednesday, July 9, 2014

Two Luther statues: a good laugh... or weeping?

I am postponing the final installment of Walther's 1859/1880 LDJ essay (see Part 1 for Table of Contents) because of one particular quote that I ran across and I want to expand on it even before I present the whole final Part 32.  To preface this, in an earlier blog post, I quoted Franz Pieper who wrote about Walther's praise of Martin Luther, especially in his polemical writings.  I have to laugh at the beginning of this quote:
"It's all entertaining. That Luther speaks so bluntly is because he fought either the Antichrist or miserable fanatics. You cannot cure all diseases with buttermilk and honey, but also bitter medicine must be given.  Luther had a thousand year old oak tree of enormous extent before him, therefore he could not cut with a penknife but had to use huge axes and sharp saws.  His heart would melt with sorrow over the poor souls who sat in darkness.  Whoever stumbles over Luther's zeal, stumbles against God who has chosen such a tool." – C.F.W. Walther
Now compare this to Walther's statement in his 1859 LDJ essay:
Therefore the whole of Europe once sat at his [Luther's] feet; hence also it yet now comes that an iron monument of him is being built at Worms [Germany] in which we admittedly take no part, but rather we prefer to place a monument to him in our hearts by accepting his doctrine.
With the ease that the Internet allows me to do this, I could not resist showing the reader what Walther is talking about of the "iron monument of [Luther] being built at Worms".  Below are 2 pictures of a Luther statue:
Two Luther statues
Left - Worms, Germany; Right - Concordia Seminary, St. Louis USA
Sources: Wikipedia–Diet at Worms and Concordia Seminary
As the caption indicates, the statue on the right, which looks very similar to the one on the left, is not the same one as that on the left.  You can read about the Worms' statue construction (in Walther's day) on the Worms.de website.  But here is what the Wikipedia article says of the one on the right, the one at Concordia Seminary-St. Louis (COSL):
The statue is an exact replica of one that exists in Worms, Germany.
Well now, that is interesting.  C.F.W. Walther just said above that --
"...we prefer to place a monument to him in our hearts by accepting his doctrine".
... yet in 1903, Concordia Seminary went ahead and built a replica of the great "iron monument" in Worms, Germany anyway, even though Walther warned against a false honoring of Luther.  Could Concordia Seminary's replica now rather be a monument to their unfaithfulness to Luther's doctrine as it is also in Germany?

I can just picture it now... someone from Concordia Seminary saying to me: "You have it all wrong.  The Worms statue isn't made of iron, its a bronze casting!"  ... and maybe add that their St. Louis statue is partly plastic? (Ha, ha, ha, ha! Psalms 59:8)

Read it and weep! you who are in the LC-MS and yet want to be faithful Lutherans!  Weep indeed...
The final installment of Walther's 1859 LDJ essay follows in Part 32...

Sunday, July 6, 2014

LDJ–Pt 31(p 90-92)—Calvinists; philosophy; true Church History

     This continues from the previous Part 30 presenting a new translation of C.F.W. Walther's seminal essay in 1859 (see Part 1 for Table of Contents).  In this Part 31, Endnote [P] is concluded and takes up [Q], [R], [S], and [T].
Preachers that displace a Christianity with new philosophical principles...  of such is now Germany full, and locally in the united synods one finds such also here and there.
Hmmm, this sounds a lot like Pastor Martin Noland, a well known "conservative" pastor in the LC-MS who said (in honor of Walther no less!):
A better way out of Lessing's Ditch is suggested by American philosopher Alvin Goldman, professor of philosophy at Rutgers Univer­sity.  Goldman is a leading proponent of "reliabilism," which posits "degrees of reasonableness" instead of the false dilemma of either certainty or uncertainty.  Also useful is the work of Richard Swinburne, professor of philosophy at Oxford, who has demonstrated that the existence of God is the most "reasonable" explanation for the universe, though it cannot be "proven" by traditional logic or scientific means.
Hmmm, sounds like Walther's targeted false teachers are now also alive and thriving in the Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod, the LC-MS.
     Underlining follows Walther's emphasis in original.  Hypertext links have been copiously added for reference to original sources and on several subjects.  Highlighting is mine.
= = = = = = = = = = = =  Part 31: Pages 90-92 (1880)  = = = = = = = = = = = =
(cont'd from Part 30)
The Lutheran Doctrine of Justification.
[by C.F.W. Walther]
Should the question be raised here by someone how the truth that there is no God outside of Christ harmonizes with the article on the Trinity? thus is to be answered to it: There is no difference in the nature of the three persons of the Godhead, which is why it also cannot be divided.  Nevertheless, what appears three times in the Trinity, namely the personhood, occurs only once in Christ. Whoever but for this cause still wants to acknowledge God apart from Christ, removes the consubstantiality between Son [W1859-62] and Father and must take several gods or deny the real essence of the complete fullness of the divinity [Essays1-61] in Christ [see Col. 2:9].  When Christ lay in the manger and hung on the cross, there was no other God than just whom was in the crib and on the cross. Admittedly one may not come here with mathematical calculations; when the mystery of the Trinity should cease being a mystery to us, we must first understand what the words "born" and “assume” mean as used of the persons of the Godhead. If one objects against us, how the Godhead could have become so small as to live in the flesh [incarnate] in the man Jesus? so we answer: No change went on in the Godhead through the personal union with human nature: it did not thereby become smaller, but human nature became greater.  Human nature did not take on the divine nature, but conversely, the divine nature has taken on the human nature.  When, however, Zwingli did not want that the Word became flesh [John 1:14], but held that it only meant that: “the Word is the flesh that it has become” (das Wort ist gewordenes Fleisch), i.e., through the incarnation of Christ he ceased to be God, and his divinity was, so to speak, transformed in Jesus into humanity (for only so was He said to be able to die), and only after that did He again become great and God: so here we hear today’s ill-formed theology.
[Q] In view of the Reformed doctrine of God’s gracious will and call of grace, at last it becomes also quite clear that [1880-91] every thought must vanish of an essential unity of the Lutheran and  Reformed Church, of which so many today let themselves dream.  A Calvinist surely overturns the doctrine of justification and can give no afflicted one certainty of divine grace, but must according to his teachings and so far as is in him, leave one to despair.  If it is not certain that Christ has redeemed all, then can the individual not without  extraordinary direct revelation become certain of his personal redemption as, conversely, if Christ has redeemed all, then also everyone can confidently make use of it for himself.
[R] There could be a great historical work written about how the consciousness that the Evangelical Lutheran Church alone was entrusted with the doctrine of justification has dwindled even within this our church, beginning with the period right after Luther’s death, just as he also foretold that the shameful ingratitude over against the gracious revelation of the Gospel would turn God’s grace into anger. And from there on, how an always growing apostasy has occurred, awakened again only now and then by God's grace. Here we should meanwhile give just those reasons for this which everyone can see without having to take the word of others.
It needs no special proof that now initially at the beginning about 100 years ago when reigned such preachers of our church which paid homage to rationalism and supernaturalism, almost all the voices of orthodoxy fell silent.  Their number has, thank God! since 1817 and especially since 1830 rather abated; but there still are too many such rationalists and supernaturalists, especially in Germany, and here as the main constituent in the united synods. [W1859-63]
[S] Preachers that displace a Christianity with new philosophical [1880-92] principles and leaven it with old heresies are now the so-called believers where the “reason faith” of rationalists is simply too unreasonable.  And they therefore trim down a Christianity to that which will please even the philosophers, whereby they use biblical words to dazzle the poor people.  Of such is now Germany full, and locally in the united synods one finds such also here and there.
[T] The “United” people cry over us that our mouth is always full of praise for purity of doctrine and not first of all for love.  They want to reap love from among their people without spreading the seeds of pure doctrine, from which alone it can grow, indeed, without considering that true love, above all, wants to save his neighbor, and that this, in turn, can be done only through the pure Word of God.  Their constant talk of works shows that they have fallen away from Christ. At the same time they themselves sin so grossly against love that they condemn our persons, whereas we condemn only all false doctrine, and in reference to doctrine cannot forgive, because it is not our property, but God’s, and we gladly hold everyone as pious while recognizing ourselves for poor sinners.  A United preacher is like a man who has been placed as steward by a rich man over his goods, and then steals from the goods entrusted to him and most generously distributes them in order to be praised by the people as exceedingly caring.  The entrusted treasure is the Word of God, dearly bought by the blood of Christ. The preacher is accursed who draws at his pleasure from this treasure to be pleasing to men!  He will stand at the last day as the wicked servant, because he has declared that it is indifferent whether one understands this or that word one way or another.  After our flesh we also would indeed [1880-93] prefer the people’s approval, rather than have their displeasure.
= = = = = = = = =  cont'd in Part 32  = = = = = = = = =

Walther is attacked today by those who oppose Universal, Objective Justification (UOJ) also on his person (ad hominem).  He addresses those types this way:
At the same time they themselves sin so grossly against love that they condemn our persons, whereas we condemn only all false doctrine.
But it is more than his chief attackers that Walther concerns himself with, it is also the pastors of his beloved (German) Missouri Synod and so he gives them this stern warning not to trifle with God's Word "in order to be praised by the people as exceedingly caring" and that those who do trifle with it, will
... stand at the last day as the wicked servant, because he has declared that it is indifferent whether one understands this or that word one way or another.
If that does not sound like Martin Luther to you, then you don't know Luther.  Walther said above that
...the gracious revelation of the Gospel... [is] awakened again only now and then by God's grace.
Those in attendance at this convention in 1859 and the old (German) Missouri Synod as a whole were truly experiencing that awakening by God's grace the same as Luther's Reformation.

In the last Part 32...

Saturday, July 5, 2014

LDJ–Pt 30(p 87-89)—objective Word, not feelings; Justification the reason for Christology

     This continues from the previous Part 29 presenting a new translation of C.F.W. Walther's seminal essay in 1859 (see Part 1 for Table of Contents).  In this Part 30, Endnote [N] is concluded and takes up [O] and [P].
     While our modern world thinks it knows Luther inside out, Walther turns things around by saying:
Stroke by stroke Luther paints the Christianity of our time. ...Only then is the power of faith right when one feels that he lies completely under the devil, yet knows that he triumphs over him by faith in the Word.
How is that for true teaching about our feelings?  We can surely feel that we are under the power of the devil, but we cannot feel our way to overcome him, but rather must look away from our feelings to the Word and believe it.  This is what the objective Word means... and Luther and Walther bring us to it, and away from our feelings.
     Underlining follows Walther's emphasis in original.  Hypertext links have been copiously added for reference to original sources and on several subjects.  Highlighting is mine.
= = = = = = = = = = = =  Part 30: Pages 87-89 (1880)  = = = = = = = = = = = =
(cont'd from Part 29)
The Lutheran Doctrine of Justification.
[by C.F.W. Walther]
Why is there so [1880-87] little of it, except because of the false doctrine about faith? Whoever stands truly in the faith despises no sinner: once he confesses Christ and adheres to Him, he is dearer, higher, and more precious to him than all the emperors of the world, and even were he the least person of all; when one reckons others as fellow guests at the table of Christ's grace, there is true love.  Indeed, the believer will be without much complaint when put upon, because: “he to whom much is forgiven, he loveth much” [cf. Luke 7:47].  In contrast, the alleged love by the sects is nothing else than a bare complimenting [Essays1-60] of the holiness in each other.  We ourselves even see — unfortunately! — also only too often first the holiness and great works in the neighbor and bow before them.  So long as our heart has not become sure of the love of God, again it cannot love: it cannot burn with love so long as its fire has not been ignited through the Gospel.  All  modern Christianity does not want to believe God on His bare Word, — wanting only to believe if first one feels the grace within himself and thinks one can be certain by himself.  That is in fact nothing else than to suffer shipwreck of faith, and is glorified however as the highest humility and piety.
[O] Stroke by stroke Luther paints the Christianity of our time.  Only in himself does one want to look for Christ and will not rather be content until he allegedly finds him there.  It is customary only to ask,, “Do you have Christ in your heart? do you feel how he works in it?”  If he says the answer “Yes!” only then will there be comfort and hope, then one will believe, as indeed for example a Methodist comforts no one until he says that he feels Christ in the heart.  But what one thus calls faith is not faith, but a pure illusion or, at best, a fruit of faith.  Woe to him who trusts on that!  because this means making a false Christ for oneself [1880-88] and rejects the Christ who hung on the cross and gives himself to us in the Gospel.  A tree remains a tree, also in winter when it shows no fruit, indeed no blossoms or leaves, and seems quite dead: so a Christian remains a Christian so long as he seizes the merit of Christ by faith in the Gospel, even if he feels nothing of Christ, indeed nothing but death in the heart. — Incomparable is Luther's use of the word, that Christ is to be found only in that which is the Father’s, i.e., in the Word of God, is in direct opposition to such a Christianity whereby one wants to look for Him within oneself and, in contrast, condemns as literal and dead faith the faith in the Word, assent to the divine promises for the person of the individual Christian, despite all feelings of personal unworthiness.  Only then is the power of faith right when one feels that he lies completely under the devil, yet knows [W1859-61] that he triumphs over him by faith in the Word.  Only so is the First Commandment fulfilled and God given all glory, and precisely for this to be done, God does not take us to heaven right after Baptism, but lets us suffer crosses, tribulations, temptations from within and without, and finally also death, and yet withal bids us to firmly believe that Christ, righteousness, peace, life, and salvation are ours. This is then also the true holiness, if one can speak so in faith, “I am nothing but an accursed speck of dust: but my God gives me, in Christ, all in all.”
[P] The Reformed sects also overturn the doctrine of justification by their false doctrine on the person of Christ according to Zwingli’s shameful example.  How they deny to this day that God suffered for us, that God’s blood was shed for us!  Where Scripture expressly testifies to this, they only want to see a rhetorical figure, which would put it another way than it was meant.  So one stamps the language of Holy Scripture [1880-89] to that of a rogue language.  A mere man should have died for us on Golgotha. There is no telling how someone who wants to be a Christian, can come to such ungodly teaching.  Admittedly it is indeed true that God as such cannot die, but Christ, who is true God, could die because He had taken on human nature, so that now the divinity and humanity in him form one person.  The human soul as such can indeed also not die: yet the dies the whole person, consisting of body and soul,, and indeed the soul is thereby most affected.  So is it also for us the main thing that the One who died for us is true God.  Had not God not died for us, then no one would be redeemed. But while we now can sing to our great comfort in life and in death: “O great distress! God himself is dead. on the cross he has died,” [see The Lutheran Hymnal, No. 167 “O Darkest Woe”, verse 2, music here; or No. 122 in Lutheran Worship, music here)], so is just this hymn an abomination to the true Reformed. — Completely in accordance with the coarse rationalism of Zwingli, according to which he does not seriously believe that Christ was true God and man in one person, Calvin says it would help no one if he would simply hold up Christ before God, but that God accepts Christ’s work as fully valid only because of eternal election.  Also for him is only that a man died. “Christ is God’s Son and true God” means therefore even now nothing more to the Reformed Church nothing more than that God dwelt in the Lord Jesus in a higher measure than in other people, about how he dwelt with his glory particularly in the temple at Jerusalem.  But even if the Reformed say that the whole God dwelt in Jesus, so they still know of a God outside him.  Thank God! that there are simple-minded souls among the Reformed, who hold that it is seriously meant when still there the words are used, Christ is true God and man in one person, and faith be founded on it. [1880-90]
= = = = = = = = =  cont'd in Part 31  = = = = = = = = =

In contrast to the statement attributed to Prof. David Scaer, that "All Theology Is Christology", Walther attaches the head article of the Christian faith, the doctrine of Justification, to the importance of a proper understanding of the Person of Christ, or "Christology":
The Reformed sects also overturn the doctrine of justification by their false doctrine on the person of Christ according to Zwingli’s shameful example.... So is it also for us the main thing that the One who died for us is true God.
Now we have the true sword of the Spirit against the errors of the Reformed on Christology, and don't leave the teaching of the Person of Christ ("Christology") hanging on its own... it has to do with the question of "So what?".
In the next Part 31...