Search This Blog

Friday, June 27, 2014

LDJ–Pt 25 (p72-74)—Antinomianism; Reformation Age... again? Essay ends, Endnotes begin

     This continues from the previous Part 24 presenting a new translation of C.F.W. Walther's seminal essay in 1859 (see Part 1 for Table of Contents).  In this Part 25, Walther finishes the main portion of his essay with a bang (read on).  And he says this at the end of a footnote, quite a fortuitous statement:
But since it is not the essayist’s [Walther] issue to show how justification is to be rightly preached, he breaks off this matter, leaving the solution of this important task to one more experienced and to another time.
==>> Dear Prof. Walther, there was no one more experienced than you and it was you who later taught us The Proper Distinction Between Law and Gospel. [text here]
     Then begins the Endnotes section and I will hyperlink each endnote to its original section.  Endnotes [A] and [B] are in this section.  These Endnotes are pure Walther even though they are presented in a format of a "discussion".  Wherever Walther was in attendance at any convention of the old (German) Missouri Synod, or at any ecumenical discussions (e.g. Pastoral Conferences), you can be absolutely certain the essay and discussions that ensued were trustworthy whether they were presented by Walther or another person.  Why?  Because Walther would never let bad theology or unclear statements be published without correction.
     Contained in this section is a footnote where Walther answers the so-called Antinomians, or those who would do away with the preaching of the Law.  Walther's caution against Antinomians trumps all of today's theologians who purport to defend against this error.  Why?  Because Walther (and Luther) taught the pure sweet Gospel properly distinguished from the Law... and so when Walther preached the Law, it was presented for its true spiritual purpose - it killeth. (2 Cor. 3:6)
    Underlining follows Walther's emphasis in original.  Hypertext links have been copiously added for reference to original sources and on several subjects.  Highlighting is mine.
= = = = = = = = = = = =  Part 25: Pages 72-74 (1880)  = = = = = = = = = = = =
(cont'd from Part 24)
The Lutheran Doctrine of Justification.
[by C.F.W. Walther]
the pure doctrine of justification [1880-72] as the root, the central point, and the crown of all doctrine. (*) [Endnote W] [W1859-52]
2. On the part of the listeners, however, it will be necessary above all that they be introduced to this pure pasture of the sweet Gospel, which alone makes one willing and cheerful for good works, also in particular that they be established in Luther’s writings and have awakened within them the joy of reading the same, the understanding of them
–––––––––––––––
*) Hereby, we finally notice,  it is in no way meant that also the Law should not and must not be preached in all its sharpness, rather the pure doctrine of justification puts such preaching ahead, without which preaching of the Law it can not be pure at all.  The justification preached in the fullness of its comfort is in no way the saltless sweetish Herrnhutish [see Moravian Church] playing with comforting features of the Gospel. In fact, even the constant prominence of comforting [truths] is not the essence of pure, uncurtailed preaching of the doctrine of justification.  Not every preacher can, given the differing natures of the congregations, give consolation to the same extent as Luther did in his early writings.  He speaks of this himself as follows: “Therefore the antinomians (Law strikers) justly deserve to have everyone hostile towards them as they would try to remain and defend with our example; even though it is manifest why we taught about God’s  [Essays1-55] grace in the beginning as we did.  The cursed pope had fully suppressed poor consciences with his man-made traditions, had taken away all true means, help, and comfort with which poor, fearful hearts might have been saved from despair: what, then, should we have done at that time other than again to raise up the oppressed and burdened hearts and hold out true consolation?  But we also know well that one must speak differently to those who are flush, tender and fat.  At that time we were all cast out and exceedingly miserable.  The water in the bottle was gone, that is, there was no comfort available. We were lying there dying, just like Ishmael under the shrub.  Therefore we needed such teachers who presented the grace of God to us and taught us how we might be refreshed. But the antinomians would have it that one must begin the doctrine of repentance simply with grace; but I myself did not proceed in this manner.  For I well knew that Ishmael was first driven out and despondent before he was comforted by an angel.  Therefore I followed that example and comforted no one except only those who first felt remorse and sorrow for their sin and had despaired of themselves, whom the Law had frightened, whom Leviathan had crushed and totally stunned.” (On Gen. 21:15-16, [Walch vol. 1, cols 2144-2145, paragrs. 174-176; StL Ed. vol 1, cols. 1428-1429, paragrs 2144-2145; cf. Am. Ed. vol. 4, 50 f.])  But since it is not the essayist’s issue to show how justification is to be rightly preached, he breaks off this matter, leaving the solution of this important task to one more experienced and to another time.
––––––––––––

[1880-73] be conveyed and developed, be shown, without exception, the essential distinction and advantage between them and all other human devotional tracts, and pointed to the proper use of the treasures contained therein of luminous knowledge and deep Christian experience.
The essayist does not doubt that if this happens, not only would soon return to its members the faded consciousness that the Evangelical Lutheran Church alone has been entrusted with the pure doctrine of Justification, but with the return thereof by the repossession of this most precious doctrinal jewel, the blessing would be renewed like the age of the Reformation which was so rich, comparable only with that of the apostles.
––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––
There were in-depth discussions, whose summary is included in the following on the reading of each point.  Everyone will readily see that the Synod did not only let Luther, etc., speak, but that the presenter’s own heart has played a part.  The well-disposed reader will want to remember that in such a completely open conference the comments on this or that point in the essay often anticipated what really belonged to one of the following points.  Still it will be dear to many and they will be served toward better understanding by the fact that we have shown through back and forth  looking references with roman letters, the points of the essay referred to by the relevant comments.
[A] It is mostly a matter of tradition to praise the article of justification by faith alone as the main doctrine: but very few fully appreciate the wealth of wonderful testimonies of our fathers on this point and the incomparable confession contained therein; yes, for the most part they do not understand what justifying [1880-74] faith is, and often take the word faith for the whole Christian religion, as everyone imagines it in his own way.  If the sects read these testimonies, so they agree well with the praise of faith, but they take their devotion, their feelings, and their activity to be faith, while Luther by it understands nothing else than the sole vision towards God’s promises and seizing and appropriating them, despite the fact that the heart sees nothing but sin and wrath, death and damnation, but he understands the faith of the sects as a dream and foam faith.  We ourselves are far from understanding the pertinent testimonies in their full power, so that we have continued to study on it, how Luther drew forth this article of justification from the well of God’s Word, where he will then become so new to us again every day, as if we never heard him before. [W1859-53]
[B] One often does not know why Luther calls the article of justifying faith difficult, which nevertheless seems so easy to many; but such one does not understand Luther.  For many it may, through God’s grace, not be so difficult to have a good sermon on justification: but Luther speaks here about the whole nature and way of treating the work of Christ in such a way that not only every other doctrine is influenced by the doctrine of justification, but that it appears as its necessary component.  That is hard — so hard that no fanatical spirit, no one who does not have the Holy Spirit can somehow do it.  Incidentally to note, we can and should learn from this to judge Luther differently than it usually happens today, since in many cases what is called his weakness is just his strength. — Luther wants to know all other doctrines drawn from the depths of the doctrine of justification; whatever does not flow from it is for him a shameful denial of Christ.  If we compel the doctrine of justifying faith in this way, it will [1880-75] become evident that the sects (Methodists, followers of [Jacob] Albright [Albrechtsleute, see Evangelical Association], etc.)...
= = = = = = = = =  cont'd in Part 26  = = = = = = = = =

So many quotes to take from this section. The editor of this essay's publication injected this comment as he spoke for his Missouri Synod about the essayist Walther:
Everyone will readily see that the Synod did not only let Luther, etc., speak, but that the presenter’s own heart has played a part.
This statement shows that the old (German) Missouri Synod knew that the essayist Walther who stood before them had a heart like that of Martin Luther himself.  Yes, even the glorious splendor of the age of the Reformation was returning before their very eyes and ears.  No wonder President Wyneken was so thrilled at Walther's essay as he extolled it in his speech before the 1860 Synod convention (see here). — Later on Walther said this:
...we can and should learn ... to judge Luther differently than it usually happens today, since in many cases what is called his weakness is just his strength.
Are you listening, editors at CPH and editors Mayes and Brown of the American Edition of Luther's Works?
In the next Part 26...

Tuesday, June 24, 2014

LDJ–Part 24 (p 69-71)—Teachers have lost it (proper distinction); comfort for dying days

     This continues from the previous Part 23 presenting a new translation of C.F.W. Walther's seminal essay in 1859 (see Part 1 for Table of Contents).  In this Part 24, Walther finishes his quote from Johann Gerhard against the Reformed and Calvinism and then begins his own analysis of the sorry state of affairs even within the Lutheran Church.  Now Walther is speaking directly to us in our "modern" world...  here is how he begins his "Part II":
How is it that the consciousness that the Evangelical Lutheran Church alone is entrusted with the pure doctrine of justification is often faded away even within this our church?
The short answer to this question is: Because most of the teachers of the same have themselves lost this gem.
How damning is that?  When the teachers have lost it, then all the "catechization" that President Lawrence Rast of CTS-FW promotes as the answer to the problems in the LC-MS is for nothing...  Read on for more on Walther's analysis of (and solutions for) today's problem in the Lutheran Church.
     Underlining follows Walther's emphasis in original.  Hypertext links have been copiously added for reference to original sources and on several subjects.  Highlighting is mine.
= = = = = = = = = = = =  Part 24: Pages 69-71 (1880)  = = = = = = = = = = = =
(cont'd from Part 23)
The Lutheran Doctrine of Justification.
[by C.F.W. Walther]
But from this they have removed and outlawed the sacramental union of the body and blood [1880-69] of Christ long ago and only kept a figurative presence, i.e., only lets remain the presence of a far, far absent body of Christ.  
Or to the goodness of Christ the Mediator?  But they hold so sure that same is present for us only according to His divine nature (which is a consuming fire), but that the human nature of Christ, according to which He is our Brother, is as far distant from us as the [W1859-50] highest heaven is from the lowest earth.  
Or to the feeling of faith?  But the feeling of faith often disappears in our hearts, especially in time of temptation.  The distressed one will therefore conclude: I don’t feel faith, so I do not have faith, therefore God doesn’t want that I have faith, so I am  in the number of the reprobate.
Or to the hallmarks of faith?  But what hallmarks are cited by the opponents as signs of faith can also be pointed out in those who have fallen from the grace of God; but, now, according to the assumption of the opponents, the latter have never had the true faith;  so no one can be sure that he has the true faith of the elect.  [Essays1-54]
Or to the office of the Word and the Sacraments?  But the distressed one will answer from Beza: He offends against God which holds that God either to men by whose mouth God speaks, or to the outward Word of God itself, or the sacramental signs even the slightest part of this His divine truth for the renewal of people and for their preservation ascribes to eternal life in Christ.   If we want, hence, that the purity of the heavenly doctrine and the basis of our faith remain unscathed, we may absolutely not allow dreaming of religious co-mingling, or disguise these heresies as unimportant, but must defend the truth with all our power.” (Loci theologici, Locus de bonis operibus. Epist. dedicator.)  [Endnote Q]
II.
How is it that the consciousness that the Evangelical Lutheran Church alone is entrusted with the pure doctrine of justification is often faded away even within this our church?
The short answer to this question is: Because most of the teachers of the same have themselves lost this gem.
1. A portion of them still pay homage namely to the vulgar rationalism and the Pelagian so-called supernaturalism.  [Endnote R]
2. Another part preaches a modified Christianity with many principles of modern philosophy and, in consequence of that, newly warmed over with all sorts of rehashed old heresies.  [Endnote S]
3. A third part has drunk from the cup of delirium with the spirit of unionism of our time and, intoxicated by it, this part considers purity of doctrine unimportant and sets true Christianity [1] in a love that is not zealous for the truth, even indifferent to it, and [2] in external common works for the extension of the kingdom of God and for remedying also certain carnal distresses of our time.  [Endnote T]
4. A fourth part seeks salvation in fanatical excitement of feelings through all sorts of new measures in contempt of God’s means of grace.  [Endnote U]
5. A fifth part consists of those who have indeed recognized the ungodly nature of unionism (der Union), but now, in opposition to the Reformed, instead of on the pure doctrine of justification, lays the main stress on outward ecclesiasticism, on the visibility of the true church, on its ceremonies, orders, and constitution, on the office of the ministry as [W1859-51] a special level generated by ordination [1880-71] and its privileged intermediation of grace, on the effect of the sacraments ex opere operato (i.e., by the mere use apart from faith), and so forth. And in part, besides all this, they either are themselves given to various favorite errors that have become fashionable in our time among the so-called “faithful,” e.g., chiliasm, the hades doctrine [see LuW 1871 Oct., Nov. Dec.; pgs 289 ff.], etc., or at least want particularly these heresies to be tolerated in the church as relating to open questions [see LuW April 1868 pgs 100 ff.], and not infrequently in a driven way try to create and preserve (treiberisch) a legalistic godliness. [Endnote V]
III.
What measures should be taken to wake up that lost consciousness again?
Should that consciousness come to life again in our church, so it is necessary:

1. On the part of the servants of the church, that they before all study diligently, next to God’s Word and especially the epistles of Paul, the precious Confessions of our church with humble and heartfelt desire for knowledge of the pure evangelical truth; and, among all our fathers in instruction, to choose Luther, in order to learn from him, with fervent invocation for the enlightenment of the Holy Spirit, the true preaching of the righteousness that is valid before God and, what is most dearly connected thereto, the proper distinction between Law and Gospel; and then, that they, the pastors, proving all faithfulness in this better knowledge thus attained by God’s grace, untiringly compel the pure doctrine of justification as the basic and chief doctrine, imprint it in their hearers, and conform all their sermons, catechism instruction, private teaching, exhortations, punishments, consolations, counseling, in short, their whole care of souls and congregational leadership to the pure doctrine of justification [1880-72] as the root, the central point, and the crown of all doctrine. *)  [Endnote W] [W1859-52]
= = = = = = = = =  cont'd in Part 25  = = = = = = = = =

What measures does Walther recommend to wake up a slumbering Lutheran Church:
  1. Study the Confessions; 
  2. choose Luther above all teachers of our Church to follow; and 
  3. thereby learn the proper distinction between Law and Gospel.  And then apply it to all the souls under their care.  
Good advice for:
  • Norma Muench at CPH – now you can read the whole essay that I recommended to you before.
  • President Lawrence Rast at CTS-FW – here is the better answer from Walther to the problems of your LC-MS than your simple "catechization" answer.
  • Harold Senkbeil of Doxology.us – to replace your useless and harmful psychology based pastoral training.
  • Prof. (emeritus) Robert Kolb – do you still think psychology and sociology can stand up to the pure teaching of the Lutheran Doctrine of Justification? (lecture video at 16:14 - 16:36 mark)
  • President Matthew Harrison – here is the answer to your great need for "here and now" teaching.
  • Pastor Klemet Preus (son of Robt. Preus) – in your dying days, don't these measures that Walther recommends for the Lutheran Church confirm what you seem to say in your writings?  ...where Walther says "that the pure doctrine of justification is the root, the central point, and the crown of all doctrine"?... that there is indeed no reason to doubt John 3:16?  Don't they comfort you in your dying days?
Yes indeed! It is good advice... for me! ... for all eternity!  In the next Part 25...

Monday, May 19, 2014

Eberle of Germany, faithful Lutheran in 1859 (uncovered gem)

I am interrupting this LDJ series to publish the complete article that C.F.W. Walther quoted in his essay.  The article was published in the first issue of 1859 in the journal Zeitschrift für Protestantismus und Kirche, and dealt with the "Union Question", which was evidently a proposal of union between Lutherans and Reformed in Württemburg (or Wuerttemburg) Germany – article in Wikipedia here.  Notably, this church seems to still calls itself "Lutheran".

So why would I take a whole blog post to publish this article?  Because C.F.W. Walther saw in it a wonderful spark of life in his native country of Germany...  a spark that excited him enough to include portions of it in his essay on The Lutheran Doctrine of Justification, in footnotes to pages 66 and 67 of the 1880 book (pages 48 & 49 of original 1859 report).  After downloading Eberle's article and researching it a bit, I believe that Walther would have gladly included almost all of it if he had the time and space to present it to his dear Missouri Synod.  So with the advantage of the Internet at my disposal, I, BackToLuther, will publish a great German pastor/theologian's essay as it relates to
the difference between John Calvin and Martin Luther.
Who was Christian Gustav Eberle (or Chr. G. Eberle):
Eberle, Christian Gustav, a Lutheran minister of Germany, was born in 1813, and died Dec. 9, 1870, at Ochsenbach, in Würtemberg. He published, Luthers Glaubensrichtung (Stuttgard, 1858): — Luther ein Zeichen dein widersprochen wird (ibid. 1860): — Luthers Evangelien-Auslegung aus seinen homiletischen und exegetischen Werken (ibid. 1857). See Zuchold, Bibl. Theol. i, 302. (B. P.)
Because of its importance to C.F.W. Walther, I have taken a few weeks to translate the entire essay, 14 pages.  The subject matter is of no small significance.  Eberle deals with
  • certainty of salvation
  • how Luther's theology developed different than Calvin's
  • objective versus subjective, a heart faith versus a head faith
  • how modern theology loses its way
  • Germany's struggles with unionism
  • Communion fellowship issues
Below I present my full translation into English of this article (German text here):

Some quotable quotes:
  • ...so many these days, of which you can hear the remark: they are not able to decide between Luther and Calvin in the doctrine of Communion, but feel attracted to Luther
  • Luther was "... as one who came immediately from the prayer chamber or from the battlefield: while the works of modern theology are for the most part taken in on the very first page entirely in the study and the library room
  • This more artificial way to win the truth can but not place Calvin as an equal alongside Luther, as a reformer beside reformer.
  • [the Union, or unionism] deprives objective certainty for those that search for certainty of their salvation in Christ and puts it on the vacillating ground of subjective conviction.
  •  it is a hundred times easier to believe a general truth [i.e. the Gospel] than to personally appropriate to oneself what it says
The red text in the essay indicates that there are a few areas that seemed questionable relating to Communion fellowship between Reformed and Lutherans.  These seemed a bit odd to me as most of the essay brought out the differences in doctrine quite well.  I believe Walther would have also questioned Eberle on these points.  Nevertheless Walther found wonderful passages of comfort in Eberle's essay and so wanted to include them in his own essay.  Especially his use of the term "objective certainty of salvation" sparked Walther's enthusiasm.  How Walther's heart ached over the ravages of unionism in his former country of Germany.  But Eberle remained as a watchman on the walls, Isaiah 62:6.

Indeed, Württemberg Germany, you can point not only to the famous follower of Luther, Johannes Brenz, but also to

Christian Gustav Eberle, 
defender of the Lutheran teaching of
objective certainty of our salvation.

I will return now to continue with Walther's essay The Lutheran Doctrine of Justification, Part 24, pages 69-71.

LDJ–Part 23 (p 66-68)—Gerhard, Eberle vs Calvinism; "chain of salvation"

     This continues from the previous Part 22 presenting a new translation of C.F.W. Walther's seminal essay in 1859 (see Part 1 for Table of Contents).  In this Part 23, Walther finishes Luther's great sermon on John 1:29 and then introduces not only John Gerhard against Calvinism, but also another more recent German pastor/theologian from his own time, Christian Gustav Eberle.  Both protest in the clearest terms against false Reformed teachings that were in large part initiated by John Calvin.  There is a phrase that Gerhard used that Walther borrowed from the – "chain of salvation".  A previous blog post showed Walther's use of this phrase as reported by Franz Pieper.  But as good as Gerhard and Eberle are, I believe there is an even better defender of the clear doctrines... the writer of this essay, C.F.W. Walther.
     Underlining follows Walther's emphasis in original.  Hypertext links have been copiously added for reference to original sources and on several subjects.  Highlighting is mine.
= = = = = = = = = = = =  Part 23: Pages 66-68 (1880)  = = = = = = = = = = = =
(cont'd from Part 22)
The Lutheran Doctrine of Justification.
[by C.F.W. Walther]
… Do you not hear, [1880-66] then, what St. John is saying here: This is the Lamb of God that takes away the sin of the world!  Now, you indeed cannot deny that you are also a part of the world. ... So you (now) are in the world and your sins are a part of the world’s sin, so stands here the text: All that denotes sin, world, and the world’s sin, from the beginning of the world until the end, all this rests solely on the Lamb of God; and because you are also a part of the world and remain in the world, so will you indeed enjoy thereof what is said at this place of the text.” (Walch W1 VII, 1639-1640, 1642, 1648-1650; paragrs. 385, 389, 398, 399, 400-401; StL Ed. 7, , paragrs. 385, 389, 398, 399, 400-401; [cf. Am. Ed. 22, 162-165, 168 f.])
How the Calvinists, with their doctrine of unconditional predestination and related errors, no troubled conscience can truly comfort and make certain of his salvation, shows Gerhard.  (*)  He
––––––––––––
*) So just here the essayist read from the Erlanger Zeitschrift (in the first issue of the year 1859) the following judgement by Eberle, well known to have eagerly studied Luther: “The eternal election to salvation is what Calvin rests on; it should offer him the objective certainty of his state of grace. And what did Luther want with his doctrine of the means of grace?  ‘Christ in Baptism, the Lord’s Supper, or in the preaching of the divine Word — there will I find Him’  he explains himself.  In the Word, Baptism, and the Lord’s Supper he sees the means to partake of Christ, of  becoming objectively certain of his share in Him. That is the common ground in the diversity; Calvin’s doctrine of predestination [and] Luther’s doctrine of the means of grace are only different approaches to one and the same goal: to become objectively certain of one’s state of grace. …  As to which of the two ways of arriving at objective certainty is the right one, Luther’s or Calvin’s, one could scarcely remain in doubt. If I am from eternity elected by God to salvation, then, to be sure, I have therein the strongest possible objective assurance: but if I am elected? — on that I have no immediate certainty; I can gather it only from this, that by Gods power I believe in Christ. But the vacillations to which faith is subject have been discussed above. So Calvin, while trying to lead [us] beyond subjective certainty, leads [us] back to it. ... But in order to be able to rejoice in my eternal election, I must first, by another and more direct route, be certain of my state of grace.  “Luther found precisely this more direct route to certainty with his statement cited: ‘Christ in Baptism, in Communion, or in the preaching of the divine Word— that is where I will find Him.’... Calvin demands without further ado that I should believe that I as an individual have from eternity been elected, whereas thousands of others around me are supposed to have been [cont’d on 1880-67 footnote]
–––––––––


[1880-67] writes:  “It is easy to see that that [W1859-49] system of an unconditional rejection is not the golden chain of salvation, but is rather the rope by which one falls into the ruin of despair.  For what can they present a man for his consolation who is distressed either because of the sense of sin, or complains of the weakness of his faith, or is troubled by the thought that he belongs to reprobate?  Maybe they will refer him to the infinite mercy of God?  But the contested one is barred by the horrible decree of rejection, as Calvin calls it, through which God’s mercy is not little or insignificantly
–––––––––
[cont’d from 1880-66 footnote] consigned to eternal damnation. That is overburdened; for to what should I hold to? I find in Scripture no special promise made out to my name or person  [Essays1-53] spelled out.  Here is missing is a connecting tie, if it is not, as already noted, to be a subjective but wavering faith.  Otherwise is Luther. He requires of a Christian only faith in a general truth: that wherever Word and sacrament are, there is Christ.  That is not hard, for it is a hundred times easier to believe a general truth than to personally appropriate to oneself what it says, as everyone knows.  But if I have learned the Word: Where Word and sacrament are, there is Christ — and for this statement I have a foothold in Scripture, whereas I have no evidence in Scripture for my personal election from eternity — so have I not far to go for the personal application: ‘Christ is in Word and sacrament also for me.’ …   But, there is another point to be considered, [a point] that unfortunately is usually overlooked, to which we must therefore pay all the more attention: ‘As you believe, so it comes to pass for you.’  That is a keynote in Luther’s faith, and a truth that conforms equally with Scripture and with experience.  The measure of what we receive depends on the measure of our faith. (See, e.g., 2 Kings 13:14,19; Ps. 81:10, and the word of the Lord: ‘Be it unto you according to your faith.’)  The author is not afraid to repeat the statement made elsewhere: A congregation sustained by the consciousness that God can be heard and is really present among us in Word and sacrament—such a congregation is sure to have its own Pentecost Day.  Whoever and however often one believes this: Where Word and sacrament are present, there Christ is also present, that person will possess Christ not only in the age-old faith but also in living experience—[and] with Him the direct assurance of grace. That is how Luther leads a Christian by a direct and easy way to the objective certainty of his salvation—and [he does] this in a way that protects him against carnal security, for he does not hold out for him any unconditional promise for the future, but bids him daily to renew his assurance of salvation in faith” (p. 116, 123, 124-125. [cf. Zeitschrift für Protestantismus und Kirche, vol. 37-1,  “Zur Unionsfrage: Calvin's Prädestinationslehre, Luther's Lehre von den Gnadenmitteln”, PDF scan copy, marked pages in PDF here]).
–––––––––


[1880-68] made shaky.  –  Or to the merit of Christ?  But the contested one will object that Christ died only for the elect, but that he doesn’t know if he is in the number of the elect; indeed, because he was taught in the schools of the opponents, that only the human nature, not the person, of Christ died, he will answer from Calvin: ‘I confess that if one were to oppose the judgment of God with Christ, in and of Himself, no merit would accrue, for the worthiness that might earn God’s favor would never be found in a man!’  –  Or to the calling through the Word?  But the contested one will object that the inner call is one thing, the outward is another; that many are called outwardly by the Word, but God has inwardly rejected them by an unconditional decree, and of which he therefore did not want them to come.  –  Or to the promises of the Gospel?  But the contested one will object that they are not universal but apply only to those who are elect, that grace is effectively offered only to a few with the purpose that it be conferred on them, as Piscator writes.  –  Or to his Baptism, in which he had been washed of sins, born again through the Holy Spirit, and included into the covenant of God?  But the contested one will object from Beza, that neither all children, nor any, in deed and truth, are born again in the moment of being baptized, but that the blessing of rebirth only follows that act of baptism in due time, as God ordained it, when the children follow in their hearing of the Word; and, with Piscator, that it really is not even true of the elect that God has appropriated them in His covenant by circumcision itself.  –  Or on the use of Holy Communion, which was instituted to strengthen the faith?  But from this they have removed and outlawed the sacramental union of the body and blood [1880-69] of Christ long ago and only kept a figurative presence,
= = = = = = = = =  cont'd in Part 24  = = = = = = = = =

With the power of today's Internet, I was able to track down Walther's source material for the German writer "Eberle" who was "well known to have eagerly studied Luther".  What I found was an essay of great interest for today's Lutheranism.  But it was Eberle's usage of the terms "objective" and "subjective" that especially caught my eye, since these are largely misunderstood by today's theologians.  And so I have taken several weeks to translate Eberle's entire 14-page essay.  In the next post, I will present this essay in my English translation so that readers may see why Walther was so excited by this German pastor's writing.  Then I will return again in Part 24 to continue translating Walther's own essay.