Search This Blog

Wednesday, September 2, 2026

BWC1e: Pieper→Baier-Walther cross-reference (#1), updated

      This continues from Part BWC1d in a series (Table of Contents in Part BWC1) presenting Walther's edition of Baier's Compendium of Positive Theology. — The following cross-reference was presented in 2017 before all the updates became available where one could link directly to English translations of the sources. Now all links have been updated to their English sources and have been compiled in the following tables. This allows fast access for rigorous study of various topics as covered by Pieper and Walther (and Baier). — Rather than a scrollable embedded window, I am presenting the table in the blog itself so that it may be archived as a unit. What follows is the listing for Volume 1 with over 300 links (pink shaded links will be updated when the translation of Volume 3 of Baier-Walther is completed):

Christliche Dogmatik

v:ppp:xxxxx

Christian Dogmatics

ppp;nnnn

Baier-

Walther

Compendium

Notes

1:006n12

8n8

1:014

Calov’s detailed account of various derivations of the Latin religio

1:044n164

42

1:002

Baier: Theology  – Greek word composite of God and Word.

1:051n181

47

1:069

Baier: Theology is a supernatural aptitude

1:056n202

52n80

1:043, 076

Pfeiffer: no doctrine outside of those based on Scripture

1:064n225

58n87

1:005

true nature of theology, is based on Scripture

1:091n319

81

3:245 f.

Dogmaticians call doctrine of justification the fundamental article.

1:095n346

85

1:061 note e [sic?]

"fundamental doctrines" did not originate with the Church

1:099n361

88n122

1:062

not every false doctrine which by its nature is destructive of the foundation of faith … "felicitous inconsistency" (“glückliche Inkonsequenz”)

1:103n376

92

1:065

Baier: errors on non-fundamental articles  – be “on our guard lest by embracing and teaching error we rashly sin”

1:106n387

94n135

1:067 nota c

Open question: Is the soul of each individual created by God immediately (creationism) or mediately through the parents (traducianism)?

1:107n390

95n137

1:067 

1767 ed.: p 52

Open questions: “... the many questions which Scripture leaves unanswered

1:117n422

104

1:040

The subject of the operation of theology is homo peccator (the sinner) in so far as he is to be led to eternal salvation

1:158n545

138n190

1:076

Does theology constitute a system?

1:173n570

150n200

1:076

Baier prefers “analytic method” over synthetic” method of theology

1:173n572

150n201

1:029

Analytical method, however, proceeds from effect to cause or seeks to derive the whole from a particular part

1:175n583

151n204

—   

Baier is infected with the synergistic bias of his father-in-law Musaeus.  The edition of Walther, St. Louis, 1879, is not a mere reprint of Baier's compend, but by the addition of quotations has been expanded to three volumes

- - - - - - - 

In the cited quotations, not only Luther and the old theologians, but also the modern theologians of the 19th century, are abundantly cited, so that students are offered a source material which enables them to judge both the old and modern theology.  Prof. Th. Bünger has supplied a index of subject and names on this edition of Walther’s, which has been worked with great diligence and great expertise.

1:176

152

Baier discusses the last things: death, resurrection, the Judgment, and the destruction of the world immediately in connection with salvation

1:176n585

152n205

1:077

The all-important point is that the theologian observe the principle of divine revelation, not the “faith” of the theologian (Objective!)


The balance for Volume 1 is available after the jump break (Volumes 2 and 3 will come later, see below):